Showing posts with label Jim Martin. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Jim Martin. Show all posts

Sunday, 17 October 2021

In The Absence Of Isochronicity Or Synchrony


This question was asked by Jim Martin on the asflanet discussion list. Strangely, he received no replies. Halliday & Matthiessen (1999: 272): 
So the more the extent of grammatical metaphor in a text, the more that text is loaded against the learner, and against anyone who is an outsider to the register in question. It becomes elitist discourse, in which the function of constructing knowledge goes together with the function of restricting access to that knowledge, making it impenetrable to all except those who have the means of admission to the inside, or the select group of those who are already there. It is this other potential that grammatical metaphor has, for making meaning that is obscure, arcane and exclusive, that makes it ideal as a mode of discourse for establishing and maintaining status, prestige and hierarchy …

Saturday, 18 September 2021

How SFL Theory Accounts For The Structure Marker 'Of'

The structure marker of is analysed as a constituent of the embedded prepositional phrase serving as Postmodifier in the logical structure of a nominal group:
Halliday & Matthiessen (2014: 425):
We noted above that prepositional phrases serve either as Adjunct or as Postmodifier. The exception is prepositional phrases with of, which normally occur only as Postmodifier; the reason is that they are not typical prepositional phrases, because in most of its contexts of use of is functioning not as minor Process/Predicator but rather as a structure marker in the nominal group (cf. to as a structure marker in the verbal group).

Wednesday, 30 August 2017

Decoding The Politicised Aesthetics Of Appreciation By Reference To The Moral Passion Plays Of Judgement



the politicised aesthetics of appreciation
has recontextualised
the moral passion plays of judgement
Identified Token
Process: identifying: circumstantial: spatio-temporal
Identifier Value

This ineffable twaddle is from Working With Discourse (Martin & Rose 2007: 40), and critiqued here.

Sunday, 21 May 2017

The Problem Of Internal Bracketing

generic [structure potential] — the original concept in Hasan (1985): potential semantic structure of texts of a given type (genre)

[generic structure] potential  — the misreading by Martin (1992): potential structure of a genre

Wednesday, 31 August 2016

Turning SFL Metalanguage Back Onto Martin's Stratified Context


register
realises
genre
Token
Process: relational
Value
a language sub-potential
realises
a text type
a text type 
[[viewed from the system pole]]
realises
a register 
[[viewed from the instance pole]]