Thursday 13 December 2012

Material Not Behavioural


Even though 'solve' does not project, viewed 'from above', in terms of the meaning being realised, problem-solving is a cognitive mental process: coming to understand a semiotic phenomenon.

they
solved
the problem
Senser
Process: mental
Phenomenon


On the other hand, viewed 'from roundabout', such clauses can accept a Beneficiary — eg for the teacher — which is a participant in material, verbal and relational clauses only (Halliday & Matthiessen 2004: 293), thereby ruling out mental, behavioural and existential clauses.  Since the clause is clearly neither verbal nor relational, on this criterion, the clause is material.


they
solved
the problem
Actor
Process: material
Goal

So the clause combines features of mental and material processes, depending on the stratum of content — the level of symbolic abstraction — meaning or wording, it is viewed from.

Note that this is anomalously analysed as 'behavioural' in Deploying Functional Grammar (Martin, Matthiessen & Painter 2010: 125-6):


they
solved
the problem
Behaver
Process: behavioural
Phenomenon

While it is true that behavioural processes display aspects of both mental and material processes, the tension here is across strata, between semantics and lexicogrammar, not within lexicogrammar.

No comments:

Post a Comment